Skip to content
LiveGold--Silver--WTI Crude--Copper--Updated -
Katusa Research
https://katusaresearch.com/lithium-bloodbath/
Katusa Investment Insights

Lithium Bloodbath

Just like that, valuations are close to decade lows.

Lithium Bloodbath

In this week's KII:

  • The Spreadsheet That Sank Lithium: China's stockpile more than doubled in one week, on paper.
  • Six Pieces of Paper: One mine's permits mark almost every turn in lithium's rally and its crash.
  • My Tax-Loss Shopping List: Lithium stocks are down as much as 85%. I ask two questions before I buy.

If you own a lithium stock, you're red-hot angry right now.

And you have every right to be.

After coming out of a multi-year coma, stocks shot up near vertical. You rode them up through the spring, and by November they had handed the whole year back. And more.

The part that should make you angrier is the recount.

The Spreadsheet That Sank Lithium

In the first week of September, China's lithium stockpile more than doubled, and it happened on a spreadsheet.

A firm called Shanghai Metals Market counts the lithium carbonate sitting in China every week. That week it surveyed more traders and battery plants, and started counting lithium by who owns it.

The old method reported about 76,000 tonnes. The new one found 169,300, and Bloomberg reported that lithium futures fell more than 14% in three days.

Now, I'm a contrarian. I want to buy when prices get absurdly cheap and sell when they get frothy, the way gold and silver did in January.

An angry crowd and a spreadsheet panic are what make a stock cheap. And with tax-loss season coming, lithium stocks are starting to look interesting.

An All-Expenses-Paid Lithium Price Round Trip

In early January, SMM had battery-grade lithium carbonate at 119,500 yuan a tonne. By May 13, it had climbed to 200,500. Today, it sits at 92,500, below where the year began.

The stocks fell harder. One North American brine developer trades 78% below its high. A Canadian hard-rock junior went from C$8.86 in January to C$1.10.

  • Put C$10,000 into that junior at the top and you'd have about C$1,240 today.

Six Pieces of Paper

You'd expect a move that size to come from mines opening and closing.

I put this year's dates in order, and almost every big turn in lithium lines up with a piece of paper.

And it starts with a mining license.

It ran out in August 2025 at CATL's Jianxiawo mine, a pit that can turn out about 3% of what the world produced last year. Reuters said the shutdown set off the surge in lithium futures and miners.

  • A safety permit on June 29 let CATL run the mine for a few weeks in July, and lithium came off its high.
  • Then people filed more than 70 formal complaints about its tailings pond. CATL stopped digging in early August, and on September 1, Benchmark reported that regulators had pulled the environmental approval.

A shut mine should have sent lithium higher, except that SMM published its recount that same week. And on October 30, Yichun's environmental bureau approved the mine all over again.

Miners moved real tonnes this year too, so I won't pin the whole crash on paper. But those dates line up with the turns in lithium stocks.

Five Lithium Forecasts, Miles Apart

What happens in 2027 depends on who you ask.

Benchmark expects a 44,000-tonne shortage and S&P Global a 163,000-tonne surplus, with three more in between.

S&P's surplus hangs on one more piece of paper. If Zimbabwe strictly enforces its raw-lithium export ban, S&P says it could flip to a 22,000-tonne shortage.

Goldman reportedly counts this year as a 404,000-tonne shortage, and lithium still lost half its price.

When forecasters disagree by that much, I put the forecasts down and pick up the balance sheets. I ask two questions.

What does it cost the company to make a tonne?

Scotiabank puts Chile's biggest brine producer near US$4,500, before what it pays the Chilean state. Find that number for anything you own and add the government’s cut.

Who's paying for the wait?

That Canadian junior sold shares at C$4.30 in January and C$2.90 in August. To raise the same money at today's C$1.10, it would have to issue nearly four times the shares it did in January.

Lithium Shopping Season Has Begun

There’s no urgency to buy yet, but somebody is already buying down here:

  • In October, a commodity trader agreed to take 100,000 tonnes from one developer over ten years.
  • In September, a buyer agreed to pay a 73% premium for an Australian junior.

On November 3, S&P Global raised its 2026 lithium demand forecast by 3.6%, the only upgrade it gave any of nine metals.

But beware, it can get even cheaper first. S&P says China’s plug-in car sales carry the most downside risk for lithium, and they fell for a tenth straight month in October.

CATL still has paperwork to clear before it digs at that re-approved mine, and tax-loss sellers have until December 30 in Canada and December 31 in the U.S.

They'll dump a junior with cash for its next milestone right beside the one that has to raise money at depressed levels.

A year ago, SMM had lithium near 81,000 yuan, and six months later it was 200,500.

So my team is starting to make our lithium watchlist now.

And I'll buy the companies that pass both questions when the forced sellers show up.

Get in the room right here

Regards,

Marin Katusa

Get real-time alerts right away. Follow on X: @KatusaResearch and @MarinKatusa


Details and Disclosures

Investing can have large potential rewards, but it can also have large potential risks. You must be aware of the risks and be willing to accept them in order to invest in financial instruments, including stocks, options, and futures. Katusa Research makes every best effort in adhering to publishing exemptions and securities laws. 

By reading this, you agree to all of the following: You understand this to be an expression of opinions and NOT professional advice. You are solely responsible for the use of any content and hold Katusa Research, and all partners, members, and affiliates harmless in any event or claim. 

If you purchase anything through a link in this email, you should assume that we have an affiliate relationship with the company providing the product or service that you purchase, and that we will be paid in some way. We recommend that you do your own independent research before purchasing anything.

Katusa Investment Insights

Actionable market insights straight to your inbox

Important disclosures

This is an expression of opinion and not professional advice. Neither Marin Katusa nor Katusa Research are registered broker-dealers or financial advisors. Past performance is not indicative of future results. When investing in speculative stocks, it is possible to lose your entire investment.

© 2026 Katusa Research / New Era Publishing Inc.